International trade law and climate change a positive. Stepping back and glancing at existing literatures may promote. Equity and international negotiations on climate change, luiz pinguellirosa and mohan munasinghe, eds. Sands, philippe, principles of international environmental law, 2nd edition. This chapter aims at identifying the epistemological role held by comparative law in relation to climate change.
In fact, legal scholarship has traditionally channeled its efforts on the climate. Fairness in adaptation to climate change looks at the challenges of ensuring that policy responses to climate change do not place undue and unfair burdens on already vulnerable. Fairness in international climate law and policy chapter. Carbon pricing and fairness1 key messages a carbon pricing policy, in the form of a carbon tax or emissions trading system ets, is a critical tool for transitioning canada to a lowcarbon economy. Pdf burden sharing and fairness principles in international. International law stays silent on the responsibility for. The declaration on human rights and climate change responds to the profound crisis of human hierarchies now characterizing the climate crisis. Climate change and international law in the grim days. Effects of fairness principles on willingness to pay for. Introduction in recent years, the effects of a changing climate from storm intensification to saltwater intrusion to desertification have lead to an increase in climate refugees, or environmental.
It is a global challenge that calls for global solutions. Box 1129 blindern, n0318 oslo, norway author for correspondence, email. The international law and politics of climate change. Fairness in international climate change regulatory regime. One obvious policy for any state serious about addressing climate change would.
General discussions sabin center for climate change law. We design, implement and sustain environmental governance advancements. Sep 14, 2015 despite this, the concerns of developing countries are marginalized in climate policy decisions that exacerbate current vulnerabilities. Fairness in adaptation to climate change the mit press. Fairness in international climate change law and policy. The ethical dimension of mitigating and adapting to climate. As a framework convention, the unfccc itself does not regulate climate change but only creates a basis for negotiating multilateral solutions. Climate change and migration, oxford university press, 2011. Jun 16, 2008 the question which this article seeks to address is whether and how international law is equipped to deal with complex global challenges such as climate change. By contrast, three recent monographs attempt to develop a principled approach re conciling the fair and the feasible in the governance of climate change.
In this article we first explore which basic principles of fairness seem to be sufficiently widely recognized to serve as a normative basis for such a scheme. International environmental law this book analyzes the law and policy for the management of global common resources. Accordingly, understanding and addressing the human consequences of climate change is a fundamental component of the climate. The international climate change regime climate change law. Soltau, friedrich, fairness in international climate change law and policy cambridge university press 2009 vanderheiden, steve, political theory and global climate change mit press 2008 verheyen, roda, climate change damage and international law. Pdf one of the major challenges facing participants in the global climate change. From the perspective of intergenerational and global justice the mitigation goals international climate negotiations are aiming for appear to be broadly the right ones. Fairness, responsibility, and climate change volume 17 issue 1 paul g. Wto compatibility of domestic and international climate policy measures.
Fairness in international climate change law and policy global. One obvious policy for any state serious about addressing climate change would be to impose low carbon standards on. However, a key concern for policymakers is how to manage the distribution of costs at the sectoral, regional and household levels. International trade law and climate change a positive way.
Gardiner very few moral philosophers have written on climate change. Accordingly, understanding and addressing the human consequences of climate change is a fundamental component of the climate change challenge. More than twenty years ago i wrote an article entitled climate change, intergenerational equity and international law. Theoretical aspects of fairness chapter 4 fairness in. International climate change law is approaching its third decade of existence, yet global greenhouse gas emissions continue to increase. The climate change regimes experiments with soft law advance our understanding of the ways in which soft law interacts with, bolsters, catalyses and complements hard law not just in the wider discipline of international environmental law, but in international law more generally.
Achievements and challenges, international spectator, 43 3, 35 50. The oxford handbook of international climate change law. Climate change and international environmental law. This is an excerpt from environment, climate change and international relations an eir edited collection. A juridical analysis of options to combat climate change will bene. The international climate change regime climate change. Absent more effective efforts to limit emissions, the range and magnitude of negative impacts climate change gives rise to will continue to deepen, posing pervasive threats to human and natural systems worldwide. International fairness and justice in addressing global climate change. Unfortunately, the same problem also afflicts other areas of international law. Climate change, intergenerational equity, and international law. Meyer professor of property and urban law, yale law school. Climate justice issues are centered largely on questions of responsibility for past ghg emissions and accountability for future emissions, often in the context of international climate change negotiations.
Climate change is the poster child of global diplomacy today. Climate change is an inherently intergenerational problem with extremely serious implications for equity between ourselves and future generations and among communities in the present and the future. Furthermore, if in force, the kyoto protocol would constitute an important international forum in which progre ssive governments can move forward to address specific issues and tensions that may arise b etween international trade law and the climate change regime. Fairness in adaptation to climate change brings together scholars from political science, economics, law, human geography, and climate science to offer the first assessment of the social justice issues in. With the link between human activities and climate change clearly established, and the first impacts of climate change being felt, there is a renewed sense of urgency in addressing the problem. Fairness, responsibility, and climate change ethics. Over forty leading scholars and practitioners set out a comprehensive understanding of the legal issues. See keohane and victor, the regime complex for climate change, infra note 18 and related text. Kraemer, r a, hinterberger, f and tarasofsky, r 2007, what contribution can trade policy make towards combating climate change. International fairness and justice in addressing global.
Climate change and international law beyond the unfccc. The chapter a provides a brief overview of the climate change problem. Find out more about eirs range of open access books here. Fairness in international climate change law and policy by. Climate justice including equity or fairness principles. Simon caney, cosmopolitan justice, responsibility, and global climate change in leiden journal of international law 2005 p. State responsibility for climate change damages by christina.
Introduction to international climate change law by daniel. Climate change and foreign policy climate change is one of the biggest challenges of this century. Soltau, fairness in international climate change law and policy, cambridge university press, 2009. Available now on amazon uk, usa, ca, ger, fra, in all good book stores, and via a free pdf download. As observed by parks and roberts, norms and principles of fairness can help cement a. Fairness in adaptation to climate change free pdf, epub. Google scholar oecd 2008 oecd environmental outlook to 2030. Cooperation under the united nations framework convention on climate change has continued to evolve from the 1997 kyoto protocol to the 2015 paris. We use cookies to enhance your experience visiting our website and to bring you content that is inline with your interests.
Chapter 3 development of the international climate change regime. Dec 11, 2014 unfortunately, the same problem also afflicts other areas of international law. Vicki been boxer family professor of law and director, furman center for real estate and urban policy, new york university school of law. Henry shue, global environment and international inequality international affairs 75, 3 1999 531. Fairness, responsibility, and climate change full text. The question which this article seeks to address is whether and how international law is equipped to deal with complex global challenges such as climate change. This is because national and international climate change policy is not determined exclusively, or even primarily, by the unfccc regime, but rather by a diffuse regime complex.
As a global society, we need to take action not only to prevent the potentially catastrophic effects of climate change but also to adapt to the unavoidable effects of climate change already imposed on the world. Nations framework convention on climate change hereinafter unfccc,16. Climate change and international law in the grim days european. The oxford handbook of international climate change law provides an unprecedented and authoritative overview of all aspects of international climate change law as it currently stands, with guidance for how it should develop in the future. Mar 25, 2019 international climate change law is approaching its third decade of existence, yet global greenhouse gas emissions continue to increase. Climate change is forcing decision makers at national and international levels to make difficult choices. Failing international climate politics and the fairness of. Chapter 2 current legal challenges in climate change justice. Despite the shift from multilateral negotiations on legally binding mitigation commitments to the decentralized nonbinding intended nationally determined contributions indcs approach in global climate policy, governments and other stakeholders continue to insist that fairness principles guide the overall effort. Burden sharing and fairness principles in international climate policy lasse ringius1, asbjorn torvanger2, and arild underdal2 1 unep collaborating centre on energy and environment, riso national laboratory, p. Burden sharing and fairness principles in international climate policy.
Burden sharing and fairness principles in international climate policy article pdf available in international environmental agreements 21. By doing so, it intends to provide food for thought not only on the role of international law in addressing climate change, but also on the impact of climate change governance on international law. The intergovernmental panel on climate changes ipcc fifth synthesis assessment report in 2014 also supports this conclusion. Key recurring principles in this debate are capacity and historical.
Stephen gardiner, ethics and global climate change, ethics 114 april 2004, 555600 p. This chapter discusses the various shortcomings of the united nations framework convention on climate change unfccc and the kyoto protocol. The conventions most evident weakness, as demonstrated during the marrakesh accords and the. National policy on climate change law 12,1872009, the law on the protection of native forests law 12,6512012, hereinafter referred as forest code, the law on the national system of conservation units law 9,9852000, related legislation, instruments and planning processes. Key recurring principles in this debate are capacity and historical responsibility. Climate change, adaptation and international relations theory. One of the major challenges facing participants in the global climate change negotiations is to find a scheme of burden sharing that can be accepted as fair by all or at least most governments. International cooperation to address the threat of climate change has become more institutionally diverse over the past decade, reflecting multiple scales of governance and the growing inclusion of climate change issues in other policy arenas.
State responsibility for climate change damages by. As competing demands on the global commons are increasing, the protection of the environment and the pursuit of growth give rise to all sorts of con. Confronted with competing demands and interests, countries are faced with committing significant resources to avoid consequences that, while beginning to be felt now, will only manifest themselves decades and, in some cases, centuries from now. Apr 14, 2017 despite the shift from multilateral negotiations on legally binding mitigation commitments to the decentralized nonbinding intended nationally determined contributions indcs approach in global climate policy, governments and other stakeholders continue to insist that fairness principles guide the overall effort. Framework convention on climate change hereinafter referred to as unfccc, which is the first multilateral basis for action to combat climate change itself, assigns a prominent place to equity and fairness. Despite this, the concerns of developing countries are marginalized in climate policy decisions that exacerbate current vulnerabilities. Ethics and climate change a study of national commitments. Special focus is given to the law on state responsibility and its capacity to deal with damages that are caused by a changing climate. Different researchers have proposed principles of fairness or. The declaration on human rights and climate change.
The intergovernmental panel on climate change s ipcc fifth synthesis assessment report in 2014 also supports this conclusion climate change is the most significant environmental challenge facing the world today, with anticipated impacts such as increasingly extreme weather events and disruption of agricultural production. First, many politicians and policy makers claim that climate change is not only the most serious environmental problem currently facing the world, but also one of the most important. A constitutional approach to unify the lex specialis. Climate change is the most significant environmental challenge facing the world today, with anticipated impacts such as increasingly extreme weather events and disruption of agricultural production. Introductory chapter to new treatise on international climate change. Iucn ethics and climate change a study of national commitments iucn environmental policy and law paper no.
Responding to the challenges of climate change routledge won a. The declaration, initiated prior to the 2015 cop 21 meeting by scholars from the global network for the study of human rights and the environment gnhre, is one of a convergence of initiatives reflecting the need to understand human rights as. Legal frameworks and proposals in the us and abroad matthew gauthier i. Addressing the global climate change problem in gattwto.
1443 32 1437 306 137 252 1254 207 1566 61 473 340 491 1007 1415 658 1302 1192 22 1071 1464 1086 626 265 701 1146 1054 1055 793 343 769 157 128